Government's Community Empowerment strategy must change to end disconnection between citizens and government
A new essay published by the Social Market Foundation suggests that if the Government's Community Empowerment strategy doesn't change, the disconnection between citizens and government will only get worse.
Community Empowerment is a defining agenda of the Brown Government. Recently, the focus of ministerial policy announcements has been on strengthening direct and participatory citizen engagement, through the use of consultations, petitions and 'citizen juries' etc. These ideas are expected to form the back-bone of the White Paper due to be published in early July.
In Disconnected Citizens: Is Community Empowerment the Solution?, Senior Research Fellow Jessica Prendergrast argues that although the government’s intentions are laudable, the structures put into place aren’t tackling the problems.
'The holy grail of greater community involvement has come to be seen as a panacea for many social ills including reducing crime, improving public health and reinvigorating democracy. However despite the rise in participatory opportunities, the reasons for people’s disconnection from representative government and distrust of representatives remain. Citizens, with limited free time, have heavy demands placed on them if they participate, only to become even more disillusioned when it becomes clear they do not have the power to really change anything.'
An alternative policy would be to strengthen links to representative democracy, by empowering councillors at the local authority and parish levels, where lines of accountability and contact between citizens and representatives can be made clear. The paper proposes an extension of parish councils in both rural and urban areas, which could provide a crucial element of reconnection.
Community Empowerment is a defining agenda of the Brown Government. Recently, the focus of ministerial policy announcements has been on strengthening direct and participatory citizen engagement, through the use of consultations, petitions and 'citizen juries' etc. These ideas are expected to form the back-bone of the White Paper due to be published in early July.
In Disconnected Citizens: Is Community Empowerment the Solution?, Senior Research Fellow Jessica Prendergrast argues that although the government’s intentions are laudable, the structures put into place aren’t tackling the problems.
'The holy grail of greater community involvement has come to be seen as a panacea for many social ills including reducing crime, improving public health and reinvigorating democracy. However despite the rise in participatory opportunities, the reasons for people’s disconnection from representative government and distrust of representatives remain. Citizens, with limited free time, have heavy demands placed on them if they participate, only to become even more disillusioned when it becomes clear they do not have the power to really change anything.'
An alternative policy would be to strengthen links to representative democracy, by empowering councillors at the local authority and parish levels, where lines of accountability and contact between citizens and representatives can be made clear. The paper proposes an extension of parish councils in both rural and urban areas, which could provide a crucial element of reconnection.
Related stories
- Government pledges 5 million to encourage new approaches to community participation
- Estate management 'hit squad' to bet set up by housing association with help from Job Centre
- Community safety and security relies on recognising residents 'as experts in their own neighbourhoods', says report
- Communities urged to propose new ideas for community life and turn power assumptions 'upside down'
- New guide aimed at councillors gives advice on creating and maintaining quality public places
- New guide focuses on achieving higher levels of community infrastructure through participation in planning
- Community Land Trusts to 'put communities centre stage in agreeing what land should be developed'
- Consultation on regeneration processes and policy across UK aims to map priorities and streamline funding
- Government frees data from OS and other public data sources for 'mash-ups', mapping schemes and new uses
- Zero carbon homes project in Nottingham grows to include neighbouring parishes as new turbine is approved
- Planning process is 'overly complex and does not involve the community, consultees or elected members effectively' says report
- Liverpool residents worked with professionals to create an exemplar sustainable community: new case study
- Neighbourhood and community empowerment can improve wellbeing, says new report
- Disused landfill sites re-invented as urban park for community outdoor activities and environmental education
- Government faces protests over planning bill independent commission plans – and eco towns
- Major new funding package for Planning Aid
- New PPS12 (Local Spatial Planning) published: key role of local authorities in the planning framework outlined
- Community takes direct action to prevent problem parking
- 'Urgent action' to cut carbon dioxide output from homes needed, says new campaign group
- Three new planning-related Bills in Government programme, including Community Empowerment: 'a mixed bag', says RTPI
